For years, Silicon Valley’s favorite instruction was simple: move fast and break things.

It sounded exciting when the things being broken were clunky interfaces, expensive middlemen, and the assumption that you needed a taxi company to get a ride. But what happens when the same attitude gets applied to institutions that millions of people depend on?

That’s the question behind my latest FUTUREPROOF. conversation with investigative journalist Jacob Silverman, author of Gilded Rage: Elon Musk and the Radicalization of Silicon Valley. The episode, “Move Fast and Break Democracy?”, was released October 27, just after the book’s paperback edition arrived in September.

And while Elon Musk is an obvious focus of the book, the conversation is really about a much bigger question: how did the people building our digital infrastructure become such consequential political actors?

The founder mythology has escaped the startup

Tech has always loved a charismatic founder. Someone who sees what the rest of us supposedly can’t, ignores conventional wisdom, and emerges victorious while everyone else is still writing a committee memo.

Sometimes that story is deserved. Building a transformative company is genuinely hard. But success in one domain doesn’t automatically confer expertise in every other one. Being brilliant at engineering rockets or scaling a platform doesn’t make someone uniquely qualified to redesign public institutions.

Yet the founder mythology encourages us to make exactly that leap. We start treating wealth as evidence of wisdom, and business success as a mandate to govern. Those are very different things.

Platforms don’t just distribute opinions. They shape the arena.

There is nothing inherently wrong with technology executives having political views. They are citizens, too. They can advocate, donate, disagree, and participate in public life.

The more difficult issue arises when an individual can simultaneously influence political debate and control a major platform where that debate takes place.

Social networks, AI systems, and digital marketplaces are not identical to governments, but they increasingly influence which ideas people encounter, which businesses get discovered, and how public arguments unfold. Their owners have legitimate business interests. The public has legitimate questions about transparency, accountability, and concentrated power.

That tension deserves more than the usual binary of “visionary entrepreneur” versus “villainous billionaire.” Both narratives are convenient. Neither tells us enough about how the underlying systems work.

The real question isn’t whether tech should be political

Silverman’s book traces the political evolution of prominent Silicon Valley figures, including Musk, Peter Thiel, and David Sacks. Our conversation explores the industry’s ideological shifts, the incentives of social platforms, and the relationship between private technological power and public authority.

One useful distinction: criticizing concentrated power is not the same as arguing that technology companies should have no voice in policy. They absolutely should. Their expertise matters when lawmakers are considering AI, privacy, competition, and digital infrastructure.

But expertise should inform democratic decisions, not replace democratic accountability. We should be skeptical whenever someone suggests that being good at building a company is a sufficient qualification to rewrite the rules for everyone else.

Who gets to decide what the future looks like?

I’ve spent much of my career studying how technology changes business and society. I’m generally excited by innovation. I also think the industry does itself no favors when it treats every demand for accountability as an attack on progress.

Progress for whom? On whose terms? And with what checks on the people making the decisions?

Those aren’t anti-technology questions. They’re exactly the questions a society should ask when a relatively small number of companies wield extraordinary influence over its information systems.

Silicon Valley promised to change the world. Mission accomplished, in many ways. The next challenge is making sure the rest of us still have a meaningful say in what comes next.

Listen to my conversation with Jacob Silverman on FUTUREPROOF.