Did Silicon Valley Break Science? What AI, Publishing, and Trust Have in Common

Silicon Valley has spent decades selling us a pretty irresistible proposition: make everything faster, cheaper, and more accessible. Remove the middlemen. Eliminate friction. Scale like crazy.

And sometimes, that works beautifully. But here’s a less comfortable question: What happens when the friction we’re removing is actually doing something important?

That’s the question at the heart of my latest FUTUREPROOF. conversation with Kent Anderson and Joy Moore, veteran scientific publishing executives and authors of How the Internet Disrupted Science. We explored how the internet transformed scientific publishing, why artificial intelligence complicates an already fragile system, and what business leaders can learn from the unintended consequences.

Listen to the November 17 FUTUREPROOF. episode: Did Silicon Valley Break Science?

Open access changed who pays, not whether someone pays

Making scientific research available beyond expensive journal subscriptions sounds like an obvious win. More people can read research. More ideas can circulate. Who’s against that?

But access and incentives are two different things.

As Kent and Joy explain, some scientific publishing models shifted the bill from readers to researchers. Instead of making money primarily from subscriptions, publishers can collect fees when articles are accepted for publication. That’s not an indictment of every open-access journal. Plenty do serious, valuable work. It does, however, create a potential conflict when publishing more material also means collecting more revenue.

Suddenly, the metric that looks like progress, more published papers, may not tell us much about the metric that actually matters: trustworthy knowledge.

AI makes content abundant. Verification becomes scarce.

Now introduce generative AI into the equation. Producing plausible-looking text is cheaper than ever. That’s useful for legitimate researchers, but it can also make low-quality submissions and fraudulent research easier to manufacture at scale.

And there’s a deliciously frustrating twist: AI may also help identify anomalies, flag suspicious submissions, and support the people responsible for maintaining research integrity.

In other words, the same technology that can flood a system with questionable material might help us defend that system. The real issue isn’t simply whether AI is good or bad for science. It’s whether our processes, incentives, and oversight can keep up.

The lesson for CEOs: Don’t optimize away trust

Here’s where this conversation moves beyond academic journals.

Every executive has some version of the same dashboard: output, speed, cost per unit, throughput. They’re useful measures. They’re also dangerously easy to mistake for outcomes.

If your customer support team closes twice as many tickets but solves fewer problems, did you improve service? If your content operation publishes five times as much but readers trust it less, did you build a stronger brand? If your AI agents complete tasks faster but nobody checks whether those tasks were worth doing, what exactly did you gain?

Scientific publishing offers a particularly stark illustration of the problem because credibility is the product. Peer review and editorial scrutiny aren’t merely annoying steps between creation and distribution. Done well, they’re part of what gives the final work value.

Of course, gatekeepers can be slow, exclusionary, and wrong. The answer isn’t to romanticize every old institution. It’s to distinguish unnecessary friction from necessary safeguards before tearing everything down.

The next competitive advantage might be knowing when to slow down

As AI makes generating information almost effortless, I suspect the premium will increasingly shift toward evaluating, contextualizing, and verifying it. More output won’t automatically mean more insight.

That’s a challenge for science, journalism, marketing, and pretty much any business currently racing to automate its workflows.

Disruption is easy to celebrate when you count what gets produced. The harder, more important question is what gets lost along the way.

And sometimes the most futureproof thing you can do is protect the step everyone else is rushing to eliminate.